Derb knows humankind
YEARNING TO BE FREE [John Derbyshire]
I’m going to side with Rich on this one. I have lived and worked among unfree human beings, on fairly intimate terms with many, and I must say, I did not notice much yearning for liberty among them. There was considerable yearning for prosperity (this was post-Mao communist China), but that is not the same thing, and in the case of China is now largely satisfied.Such yearning for liberty as I encountered was among a scattered few individuals, in whom the yearning really did seem to be instinctive. They chafed and groaned under the unfree system. They just couldn’t “fit” into it. I would estimate the overall proportion of such people as about one male in ten, the proportion among females being negligible. All those individuals now live abroad.
Most of my colleagues of that time, however, were happy, or at worst not seriously unhappy, in unfreedom. They went along with the system and didn’t see much wrong with it. If the desire for liberty is inborn in us, then it seems to me it is rather easily suppressed, except among an eccentric few. That few are, rightly, heros to us conservatives–I take Vladimir Bukovsky as their exemplar–but I’m afraid they are only a few.
The late Malcolm Muggeridge made it a habit to liberate hens from battery-farm conditions, and let them free range in his yard. He claimed that when first let loose, the hens, accustomed to spend all their time in a small wire cage, were baffled, confused, and unhappy…..
The saddest part of it all is that he is right. As the sad quote goes, “People are dumb, panicky, dangerous animals and you know it.”
I think Derb’s 90% mark is about right for Americans too. Most are too worried about their own petty problems, or are too stupid to know any difference.
But that’s OK, cuz we like, need diversity, and stuff, because diversity is good, right?